For the most part, we as leaders in scouting, use a structured, guided way of teaching using mostly activities, as opposed to classroom type learning.
Logic, rationality, critical thinking are very important when it comes to running an activity, that might contain some dangerous elements.
As an example. We look at an activity from an outsiders viewpoint to determine if it is safe, or what steps we have to take to make it safe. We also look at it from a fun perspective. If its not fun, then why would you do it. Both these points need a cold rational look at the activity, to see if it will work as intended.
Designing an activity and then hoping and praying that it will work, or that no one will get hurt, is a recipe for disaster. If you have done similar stuff before, then it isn't a big step, to translate it to a new idea. But there are unintended consequences. So a simple sit back and have another look at it, and do a proper assessment, will eventually bring better results.
In scouting the scouts themselves also run activities. So they will also need to be looking at it from this perspective. So a good grounding in critical thinking and being able to assess a situation and plan ahead is very important. So the sooner that the scouts are able pick up and use these skills the better.
So being objective, and logical when it comes to making a decision should be one of the first things that a scout should learn, and they should then pass it on to other scouts in their patrols, sixes, dens, packs or group.
I believe that Scouting has a lot to offer youth and adults all over the world, and we have an opportunity to help the people in the movement to think Rationally.
Showing posts with label science. Show all posts
Showing posts with label science. Show all posts
Monday, November 1, 2010
We are all scientists?
Are we all Scientists?
As far as I can tell, we go about our lives mostly without realising, that we make decisions based on our knowledge and experience. This is basically the same in science.
We see a problem, or something interesting, we make up our mind what it is causing it (the hypothesis), we may seek evidence or more info (testing the hypothesis), and if it is confirmed, then our belief becomes solid. If if the hypothesis is proved incorrect then we need to formulate a new idea, and so on, until the theory is so thoroughly tested that it becomes a fact (in our mind at least).
Most of this goes on on a subconcious level, is is just mundane daily stuff, not to interesting.
When an event that is way out of the ordinary happens, and the availability of evidence, is non existent, or the event happened so fast, that it was hard to pay close attention, to get more information, we tend to fill in the gaps in our knowledge, with what we already know, or have been told.
If you are not being critical in your thinking, and need an answer now, then the story you come up with may lack detail, may not be well considered, or a number of other things may happen. All leading to a result that may sound reasonable, but may not reflect the truth of the situation. Just ask a detective how many different accounts they get from a crowd of people all watching the exact same event.
So when someone exclaims something incredible. Then they must have incredible evidence to back it up. Something solid like, photo's, video, DNA, remains, documents that are related directly to the event, etc. Even then a single piece of evidence may not be enough to be conclusive.
As I mentioned earlier science is a process, not a bunch of facts.
Just ask a scientist how many times they have made a mistake. They will probably tell you outright that they have made many (it may be the mistakes that were the most interesting). The beauty in this is that you learn something from your mistakes (hopefully).
Don't trust anyone who never makes a mistake (politicians are never wrong), all it means is they don't recognise a mistake and so never correct it, or learn from it. If we don't learn from our mistakes we don't progress.
Be happy with change. Science is constantly changing. Some strong theories of the past have been overturned because of better evidence. Although for the majority of theories, new experiments and testing just refine the theory., with its broad "intent"still valid. Better designed experiments can yield more reliable results.
Just look at Andrew Wakefield, he had a hypothesis, he tested it, and came up with an interesting result. Subsequent experiments on significantly larger populations, and tightly controlled experiments have since shown his results to be incorrect. (He can't bring himself to accept these results, so doesn't learn anything new).
Embrace your mistakes, they are things you can truly call your own, but more importantly, learn from them.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)